That’s… weirdly specific. Okay, here we go. Probably not very exciting, but…

Pleasantview- witches. Bella Goth being a witch is basically canon by now. It’s hard to imagine anything else.

Strangetown- as you said. Aliens. Aliens everywhere. XD

Veronaville- I’d put the werewolf in here because waaay back I played an extended version of Veronaville (with some of the college premade sims and their family living there, too) and I turned one of them into a werewolf. Worked surprisingly well. And come on, being werewolves would explain so much of Tybalt’s (and Mercutio’s) behaviour

Downtown- vampires. First of all, all non-playable vampires live there, and second of all, don’t tell me the Tricou’s weren’t supposed to be a creepy vampire clan.

Bluewater- robots. Yes, I know, I’m mostly matching supernaturals to the EP they first appeared in, but yeah, they kind of fit the overall theme. And when I think of Chester Gieke (I know, I know, he’s technically a bin family), my mind screams “robot!” and “Aliens!” but I already used them up, sooo… Also, Malcolm Landgraab totally has a robot servant that freaks Miss Delarosa out whenever he visits her. She is old fashioned like that.

Riveblossom- well, I’m gonna say Plantsims, even though I still don’t understand why EAxis would put Sims that are basically Plants and need lots of sunlight in a town where it’s winter half the time?!

Desiderata Valley- you know what? Marcel Joque leaves his boring as f*** wife for Bigfoot and the two of them move into a cabin in the woods. Natasha befriends Bigfoot and helps him adapting to SimWorld. John Mole becomes convinced that Bigfoot is a RedNation spy. It’s a big f***ing mess and would make the most boring family in the whole family much more interesting.

Belladonna Cove- bring on the Zombie apocalypse. One of the Cordial witches probably started it by trying to turn their sister into a toad. (I feel like this would actually be a lot of fun. Imagine Armand DeBateau and Connor Weir fighting over the last can of food in a burning supermarket.)

Thanks, that was actually a lot of fun!